Honors and Awards
- Katie Garland ('12): Murray Library Research Grant (2011-2012), Boyer Scholar (2011-2012), Historic Deerfield Summer Fellowship Program
- Natalie Burack ('12): Murray Library Research Grant (2011-2012), Boyer Scholar (2011-2012)
- Janelle Schmouder ('11): Clio Award for Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2011)
- Christine Kelly ('11): Clio Award for Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2011), Murray Library Research Grant (2010-2011)
- Melissa Hogan ('11): Murray Library Research Grant (2009-2010)
- Caitlin Babcock ('10): Clio Award for Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2010), Murray Library Research Grant (2009-2010)
- Andrew Henry ('10): Clio Award for Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2010)
- Jennifer Adams ('09): Clio Award for Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2009)
- Lucy Barnhouse ('08): Messiah College Presidential Scholarship (2005); National Merit Scholar (2005); Who's Who Among American College Students (2007); Clio Award as Most Oustanding Graduating Senior ('08).
- Heather Beaver ('07): Who's Who Among American College Students (2007)
- Phil Bess ('06): Boyer Scholar (2005-2006)
- Jamie Binder ('02): Clio Award as Most Oustanding Graduating Senior (2002); Boyer Scholar (2001-2002).
- Justin Bollinger ('06): Boyer Scholar (2005-2006).
- Michelle Bomboy ('08); Earl & Joann Henry Hope Scholarship for History majors.
- Mac Brodt ('02): Boyer Scholar (2001-2002); Pew Younger Scholar (Summer 2001).
- Kevin Benedict ('02): Boyer Scholar (2001-2002).
- Danae Davis ('05): Honorable Mention, Messiah College Peace Speech Competition (2005)
- Jeff Erbig ('05): Boyer Scholar (2004-2005); Friends of Murray Library Travel Grant (2005); Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2005).
- Faith Espiritu: Lloyd and Lois Martin Multicultural Scholarship for Leadership and Academics (2005-2009)
- David Fox ('10): Who's Who Among American College Students (2009)
- Ben Friedline ('04): Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2004).
- Megan Giordano ('03): Boyer Scholar (2000-2001); Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2003); McNeil Fellow, Winterthur Museum Study in Early American Civilization (2003-2005).
- Rachel Heeter ('07): Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2007).
- Sharon Hopper ('03): Boyer Scholar (2002-2003); Bernice Samalonis Scholarship (Middle States Council for Social Studies, 2003).
- Sarah Mackin ('04): Clio Award as Most Oustanding Graduating Senior (2004); Boyer Scholar (2003-2004).
- Corinne Major ('06): Boyer Scholar (2005-2006); Smith Scholar Intern (2006-2007)
- Bethany Parliament ('02): Clio Award as Most Oustanding Graduating Senior (2002).
- Cali Pitchel ('07): Smith Scholar Intern (2006-2007)
- Andrew Sand ('06): Maryland Governor's Citation for his work at the Maryland Energy Administration and for restructuring Baltimore's Clean Cities Coalition (Summer 2004).
- Kelsey Spencer ('06): Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2006); Boyer Scholar (2005-2006); Best 50 Women in Leadership in Pennsylvania (2006); Who's Who Among American College and University Students (2006).
- Lauren Smith ('06): Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2007).
- Monica Volante ('01): Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2001).
- Elisabeth Winkler ('02): Clio Award as Most Outstanding Graduating Senior (2002).

