| Singles competition |
| 1. Will Willson (OTT) def. Michael Brookhart (MESSM) 6-0, 6-2 |
| 2. Ryan Shutt (OTT) def. David Wichert (MESSM) 6-1, 3-0, unfinished |
| 3. David Seckel (OTT) def. Peter Shuck (MESSM) 6-0, 6-2 |
| 4. Kendall Coffman (OTT) def. Devin Esch (MESSM) 6-3, 0-2, unfinished |
| 5. Zach McDivitt (OTT) def. Chris Brittingham (MESSM) 6-0, 1-4, unfinished |
| 6. Jacob Devore (OTT) def. Dustin Innerst (MESSM) 6-1, 3-2, unfinished |
| Doubles competition |
| 1. Will Willson/David Seckel (OTT) def. Michael Brookhart/David Wichert (MESSM) 8-0 |
| 2. Ryan Shutt/Zach McDivitt (OTT) def. Peter Shuck/Zachary Brunner (MESSM) 8-2 |
| 3. Tyler Gibbons/Kendall Coffman (OTT) def. Dustin Innerst/Michael Kovacs (MESSM) 8-2 |
| Match Notes |
| Otterbein 19-4 |
| Messiah College 10-7 |
| Order of finish: Doubles (1,2,3); Singles (1,3) |
| 2014 NCAA Division III Men's Tennis Championship |
| First Round - Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| T-1:42 |