The Harlem Renaissance:
Zora Neale Hurston and Claude
McKay
Zora Neale Hurston
* Personal History
Zora Neale Hurston was the first African-American woman "to create language
and imagery that reflected the reality of black women's lives" (Wall, 371).
This language and imagery that Hurston is known for was a result of the
childhood she spent in Eatonville, Florida, the first incorporated all-black
town in America. The most accepted date of her birth is January 7,
1901, but the issue has been debated because other birth dates are possible
as well.
The seventh child in a family of eight, her only sister Sarah was her father's
favorite child, so Hurston naturally drew closer to her mother. Thus,
when her mother died, while Hurston was a child, her life changed dramatically.
Hurston and two of her siblings were sent to boarding school for a year,
during which time their father re-married. Because their step-mother
did not want the responsibility of caring for them, the children were sent
to live with different relatives. After several years, Hurston left
to work for a traveling theater troupe, but left this troupe in Baltimore
so that she could continue her education.
Working her way through high school, Hurston eventually graduated from
the Morgan Academy in 1918, then spent a few years at Howard University,
in Washington, D.C. While at Howard, Hurston belonged to the campus
literary club, Stylus, which was headed by Alain Locke. Locke was
known for his dislike of women, and, at the first day of classes, he would
guarantee an automatic "C" to any female student who would not show up
to his class for the remainder of the semester. However, Hurston,
who was deeply inspired by Locke, was determined to remain involved in
Stylus until she moved to Harlem in 1925.
She began writing at this time, relying on her Southern background to create
the folklore that she would eventually become famous for. However,
her folk characters and their speech would also become her downfall, because
W.E.B. DuBois and others of the Harlem Renaissance considered folklore
too primitive to be considered true art, and they wanted writing to be
"untainted by racial
stereotype."
Hurston was further criticized because of her personality, which did not
fit the typical role prescribed for women, as evidenced by her style of
clothing and the bohemian community that she became a part of.
After receiving a scholarship to attend Barnard College, the women's division
of Columbia University, she studied under anthropologist Franz Boas, who
was to have a profound influence on her life. She used her knowledge
of anthropology to further her career as an author, returning to Eatonville
to collect data for her writing. However, because Hurston was now
so different from those in her hometown, this first trip was a failure.
Hurston's later trips were sponsored by Mrs. Charlotte Mason, who gave
her money to spend on her work but also required an exact account of how
the money was spent. "Godmother," as Mason was called by the artists
she supported, had control over Hurston's writing, including the right
to censor it. Interestingly enough, Mason also supported another
famous writer of the Harlem Renaissance, Langston Hughes, who was a close
friend of Hurston's as well. Unfortunately, Hughes' relationship
with both women was severed forever after a falling out over a play that
Hughes and Hurston had co-authored, "Mule Bone," which was never even staged
nor printed in its entirety.
Because of the problems of her first trip, Hurston adapted herself to becoming
more like the Eatonville residents on her following visits, and met with
more success. She was particularly interested in the "lying sessions,"
such as those that she remembered hearing as a child, during which each
person would compete to tell the tallest tale possible. Because of
this interest, she left Eatonville for Polk County, where, she was told,
she could find the best liars in the world. Both Eatonville and Polk
County figure largely in her writing, for her memories as well as the stories
she heard provided her with a wealth of fiction for her imagination to
explore.
In addition to folklore, voodoo became an important part of Hurston's anthropological
studies, and she went to New Orleans in 1928 in order to study this religion.
Part of its attraction was the fact that voodoo's roots are in Africa,
and Hurston was deeply interested in her black heritage. Unlike many
blacks, she was proud of her blackness, and sought to explore all of its
facets. After studying voodoo rites, including chants, prayers, songs,
dances, and ritual sacrifices of animals such as sheep, goats, or chickens,
Hurston decided to study the folklore of the Caribbean Islands.
Financed by the Guggenheim Fellowship for two years, she spent six months
in the West Jamaican mountains, among an isolated people group, the Maroons,
descendants of fugitive slaves. Hurston also made two trips to Haiti,
where she continued her study of voodoo and developed an interest in the
study of zombies. Her work in this area led to later research in
zombies, which revealed that they are actually caused by voodoo sects.
However, after falling violently ill, Hurston feared that someone was attempting
to kill her for her interest in voodoo, so she returned to the United States.
By this time in her life, Hurston's two brief love affairs had ended, both
because she could not give up her work for a man. Though she loved
these men, her work was always first in her life, for writing was her first
love. As a result of her second break-up, Hurston wrote Their
Eyes Were Watching God in 1937, while in Haiti, a novel which is often
considered her masterpiece. While white critics praised her accurate
portrayal of Negro speech, black critics rejected the novel. Hurston's
depiction of blacks as common folks working in the bean fields was considered
offensive by many, and Richard Wright, who considered writing a political
tool, thought that the story was a "waste," for it did not call attention
to the problem of inequality in America.
However, Hurston's goal was to promote the cultural heritage of black Americans,
not to discuss race relations, discrimination, Jim Crow laws, or any of
the other topics so popular with her contemporaries. Unlike many
other black Americans of the time, for Hurston "being black was a joy,
not a cross to bear; she liked herself and her color" (Lyons, 101).
Because she had grown up in an all-black community, Hurston had never even
experienced segregation until she visited Jacksonville at some point during
her childhood. But, more importantly, Eatonville convinced her of
the vitality and the promise of the black community, and she wanted to
celebrate the black culture that she loved through her writing. In
some ways, Hurston was ahead of her time, for her racial pride would have
fit in well with the black separatist movement of the 1960's, when black
would finally be considered beautiful.
Sadly, Hurston's works became more and more neglected, until she reached
the point where she was living in extreme poverty, working at whatever
odd jobs she could find. After suffering from a stroke, she moved
into a nursing home, where she died in 1973. Though her friends raised
the money for her funeral, her grave was left unmarked until Alice Walker
visited it, many years later, and erected a headstone to her memory, calling
Hurston "a genius of the South." After years of obscurity, Hurston's
work is finally being revived, and today she is considered one of the most
important black writers of the twentieth century.

* Genre
-
Novels
-
Short stories
-
Mythology/Folklore
-
Poetry
-
Autobiography
* Storytelling Techniques
When writing or telling stories, Zora Neale Hurston takes on several different
roles. While gathering information for her stories, she becomes the
listener, and while she writes her stories she takes on the role of the
informer. By the time Mules and Men was published, Hurston
was not only an expert at collecting information, but she also had the
ability to perform that information for her audience.
Hurston uses her two audiences (informants and readers) to her advantage
in taking control of the story. She pits them against one another,
allowing them to feed her creative imagination. For example, the
information the informant has may be something the reader was not aware
of, and vice versa. "Readers and informants serve her as she used
wither group to achieve whatever purpose she needs to achieve at any given
moment. As a result of such manipulation, Hurston remains...center
stage to the volume.... No matter her self-effacing, no matter her
pretended innocence, no matter her allowing other people center stage at
points, she remains the key to the success of the volume" (Harris, 9).
Hurston's
goal was to have her presence be dominate in her stories. She wanted
to manipulate her informants into giving her the information she wanted
and her readers into listening what she had to say. Because of this
she was able to write books and stories that went against the accepted
view of her time, perhaps making it possible for others to voice similar
views.
Claude McKay
*Personal History
Claude McKay, a man adopted by the black community of Harlem as a race
poet representing African-Americans, did not see himself in this light.
This native-born Jamaican had an entirely different agenda, that being
to expose the "mechanically regimented progress of Western Industrialism"
(Cooper, 31). From his childhood until the time he moved to the United
States, the world was a very different, accepting place for McKay.
Thus, when this great Harlem Renaissance poet adopted the United States
as his new home, there were several issues he wanted to address through
his writing.
Born on September 15, 1890, the youngest of eight children, McKay's life
in Jamaica was pleasant on the whole. While his family did not have
an excessive amount of money, they managed a farm and lived comfortably.
McKay's father was a strong Christian, a faith which Claude did not live
by. Still, both respected and cared for one another. And McKay
was able to read a wide variety of literature, from novels and histories,
to biblical literature and Shakespeare. He had access to a library
through a family connection, and was educated by his eldest brother, who
held a teaching degree. This was an opportunity most blacks did not
have. Socially, the concept of racism was rather foreign to him as
a boy. He did not suffer ill-effects of racism, and denied any racial
tensions at all in Jamaica, though others would later disagree with him.
When describing his life there, McKay said, "I was brought up to use the
same language to a white person as a colored" (Tillery, 18). It was
not until he arrived in the United States to go to college that the oppression
of American society became a harsh reality.
Having already had two volumes of poetry in the Jamaican dialect published
in 1912, he was ready to learn more. Arriving in Charleston, South
Carolina later that same year, he attended Tuskegee Institute, a prestigious
school for blacks, but could not handle the atmosphere of restriction and
oppression, and so he left after six months. Even there he felt the
gap between whites and blacks was incredible, as the issue of racism could
not be kept from being exposed to the students. The "protected" atmosphere
did nothing to encourage students' involvement in reshaping society and
her ideals. Rather, he found a community which encouraged living
in order to be accepted by white Americans. He found such a stand
to be weak and unappealing.
McKay moved on to Kansas State College, and after two years there, moved
to New York City when one of his literary admirers gave him several thousand
dollars out of appreciation for his Jamaican dialect works. Once
in New York, he immersed himself in the black community there. He
married Eulalie Edwars, and became a restauranteur that same summer.
However, within six months, she returned to Jamaica and gave birth to a
daughter McKay would never see, while the restaurant business lost all
of its money.
At that point, McKay decided to seriously pursue a writing career.
He started writing poetry in Standard English, a fairly conservative style.
His message was rebellion, despair, and alienation. America, which
he adopted, was not a land of joy for McKay. He was terribly bitter
about the intense hatred he felt over the color of his skin. Realizing
he was a "black poet," and not just a "poet," according to society, McKay
struggled to find a balance between "racial and universal notes" in his
poetry. Some of his poems are filled with anger and seem to have
a definite African-American slant, while others seem to speak to no particular
race at all.
At the end of World War I, in 1918, McKay embraced Socialism. He
felt American Capitalism exploited the black man, because blacks were forced
to prove themselves, yet still were never given half the chance of a white
man. So from 1919 until 1922, he wrote articles for the Liberator,
a leftist magazine targeted by the government for conspiracy. He
was bold in his accusations against the American government, and his poetry
reflected that view.
During that time McKay wrote a poem entitled, "If We Must Die," and it
enjoyed huge success among the black community because of its apparent
display of pride and strength amidst oppression and cruelty. However,
McKay said he wrote it "for all men who were being abused, brutalized,
and murdered, whether they were black, brown, yellow, or white" (Tiller,
34). McKay did not appreciate being the "black representative" for
America. He was afraid the black community would just praise him
out of racial patronage, rather than out of appreciation for his poetic/intellectual
abilities.
Then in 1922, after being co-editor of the Liberator with a Marxist,
which often raised tensions, two important things happened in McKay's life.
First, his poetic reputation was greatly enhanced when his fourth book
of verse was published, entitled Harlem Shadows. Some said
"it contained all the best poems he had written since his first arrival
in the U.S. in 1912" (Cooper, 17). He was proclaimed the best negro
poet since Paul Laurence Dunbar. And black reviewer Walter White
called McKay not a great Negro poet, but a great poet. Second, McKay
decided to leave the bitter world of America and move to Russia.
He lived there for twelve years, and enjoyed getting away from the race
consciousness that filled black American life. He became a bit of
a celebrity there, and felt proud to be African. People treated him
like a black icon in the flesh. He was the first black to arrive
in Russia since the revolution, and was considered to be a good omen.
However, the Great Depression left him penniless, and he returned to New
York in 1934 on borrowed money. He feared coming back to the harsh
conditions in America, and felt as though he had been "expelled from heaven
to hell" (Cooper, 35).
In 1937 he wrote his autobiography, A Long Way From Home, in which
he gave an account of his life in America, Europe, and North Africa.
In it he questioned the motives of blacks whom he felt used the Harlem
Renaissance to advance their social status among whites. He saw Harlem
as a "vital, but chaotically disorganized community" (Cooper, 30).
Eventually, McKay was rejected by the Harlem community because he felt
blacks could not afford to ally themselves with a party controlled by a
capitalist government. He wanted to see black community development
become a form of nationalism. Those in power in Harlem isolated him
by rejecting his ideas which were "out of touch with reality." So
by the age of 50, McKay was a bitter and isolated man, with no money, position,
or future.
Near the end of his life, after being diagnosed with hypertension and dropsy,
which weakened his heart due to fluid retention and made him appear rather
chubby, he rejected his socialist ideals and joined the Catholic Church
in 1944. He wanted refuge in a devastatingly dehumanized world, and
found personal salvation, much to the shock of his contemporaries.
His last compilation of poems written while he was alive was not published
until 1953, after his death. He died in a Chicago hospital on May
22, 1948, from heart failure.
During his lifetime he made clear his idea that blacks and black artists
should not be dependent for their development and growth on either white
patronage or passing social fashions. He never gave up that conviction.
Many of his works became the pacesetters for a new generation of black
American poets and novelists. As the white New Republic reviewer,
Robert Littel, said, "his poetry concerning whites and blacks struck hard
and pierced deep. He expressed more than just emotion. It was
something fierce and constant" (Cooper, 18). Though his life was
a struggle against not only white oppression, but also the black community
at times, as well as America in general, McKay held fast to his conviction
that color-consciousness was a devastating fire which must be put out.
Points of Interest
-
From 1918-1922 McKay wrote
22 essays, book reviews, and letters for publication.
-
During his lifetime, Claude
McKay's most widely-acclaimed book was, perhaps, Home to Harlem,
which was a national best-seller in 1928.
-
In his lifetime, McKay
held the following professions: wheelwright, constable, agriculturist,
porter, longshoreman, waiter, poet and novelist.
QUOTES
~ "Mama exhorted her children
at every opportunity to "jump at de sun." We might not land on the
sun, but at least we would get off the ground."
~ "Nothing that God
ever made is the same thing to more than one person. That is natural.
There is no single face in nature, because every eye that looks upon it,
sees it from its own angle. So every man's spice-box seasons his
own food."
~ Zora Neale Hurston
~ "All my life I have
been a troubadour wanderer, nourishing myself mainly on the poetry of existence.
And all I offer here is the distilled poetry of my experience."
~ Claude McKay
Works Cited
Cooper, Wayne F., ed.
The Passion of Claude McKay: Selected Poetry and Prose, 1912-1948.
New York: Schocken Books, 1973.
Dewey, John.
Introduction. Selected Poems of Claude McKay. By Claude
McKay. New York:
Bookman Associates, 1953.
Harris, Trudier.
The Power of the Porch: The Storyteller's Craft in Zora Neale
Hurston, Gloria
Naylor, and Randall Kenan. Athens, GA: University of Georgia
Press, 1996.
Lyons, Mary E.
Sorrow's Kitchen: The Life and Folklore of Zora Neale Hurston.
New York, NY:
Nacmillan Publkshing Co., 1990.
Tillery, Tyrone.
Claude McKay: A Black Poet's Struggle for Identity. The
University of
Massechusettes Press, 1992.
Wall, Cheryl A.
"Zora neale Hurston: Changing Her Own Words." American Novelists
Revisited:
Essays in Feminist Criticism. Ed. Fritz Fleischmann. Boston,
Massachusettes: G.K. Hall &
Co., 1982. 371-393.